Introduction
The Public Accounts Committee (PAC) is one of the most important financial committees of the Parliament of India. It plays a major role in ensuring parliamentary control over public expenditure and in examining whether money sanctioned by Parliament has been spent properly, legally and for the purposes for which it was granted.
The PAC is closely associated with the principle of financial accountability of the executive to the legislature. Since the government collects and spends public money, Parliament must have a mechanism to examine how that money has actually been used. The Public Accounts Committee performs this important scrutiny on behalf of Parliament.
The Committee mainly examines the accounts of the Union Government and the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) relating to those accounts.
---
Constitutional and Parliamentary Basis
The Public Accounts Committee is not directly created by a separate provision of the Constitution. It is a parliamentary committee constituted under the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha.
The Committee is therefore an important part of the parliamentary financial control system.
The CAG audits government accounts and submits reports to Parliament. These reports are examined by the PAC, which investigates cases of irregular expenditure, excess expenditure, financial mismanagement and other matters highlighted by the CAG.
Thus, the relationship can be understood as:
Parliament → authorises expenditure → Government spends money → CAG audits expenditure → PAC examines CAG reports → Parliament receives findings and recommendations.
---
Composition of the Public Accounts Committee
The Public Accounts Committee consists of 22 members:
- 15 members from the Lok Sabha
- 7 members from the Rajya Sabha
The members are elected by Parliament every year according to the principle of proportional representation by means of the single transferable vote.
The Committee normally has a one-year tenure.
A minister cannot be elected as a member of the Public Accounts Committee. This restriction is important because the Committee is expected to scrutinise government expenditure independently.
The Chairperson of the PAC is appointed by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha.
Since 1967, by convention, the Chairperson of the Public Accounts Committee has generally been selected from the Opposition. This convention strengthens the Committee's role in scrutinising the government.
---
Main Functions of the Public Accounts Committee
The principal responsibility of the PAC is to examine whether public money has been properly spent.
1. Examination of Appropriation Accounts
The Committee examines the Appropriation Accounts of the Government of India.
Appropriation Accounts show how the money authorised by Parliament has actually been spent by different departments and ministries.
The PAC compares:
Amount sanctioned by Parliament → Amount actually spent
If expenditure differs significantly from the amount authorised, the Committee examines the reasons.
---
2. Examination of Finance Accounts
The PAC also examines the Annual Finance Accounts of the Government of India.
Finance Accounts provide information about the government's financial transactions and position.
The Committee uses these accounts to assess whether government financial transactions have been carried out according to established rules and procedures.
---
3. Examination of CAG Reports
One of the most important functions of the PAC is to examine the reports of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India relating to government accounts.
The CAG acts as an important source of information for the Committee.
The PAC examines matters such as:
- irregular expenditure;
- excess expenditure;
- expenditure without proper authority;
- financial losses to the government;
- misuse or improper use of public money;
- failure to follow financial rules;
- cases of waste and inefficiency; and
- deficiencies in financial administration.
---
4. Examination of Excess Expenditure
If a government department spends more money than Parliament originally authorised, the PAC examines the circumstances responsible for such excess expenditure.
The Committee seeks to determine:
- why the excess expenditure occurred;
- whether it could have been avoided;
- whether proper approval was obtained; and
- whether financial discipline was maintained.
This helps Parliament exercise control over the executive's financial activities.
---
5. Examination of Financial Irregularities
The PAC investigates financial irregularities pointed out by the CAG.
For example, if the CAG identifies that a ministry failed to follow prescribed financial procedures, the PAC may examine the matter and seek explanations from the concerned authorities.
The Committee may question senior officials and seek relevant records and information within its parliamentary powers and terms of reference.
---
6. Examination of Losses and Wastage of Public Money
The Committee may examine cases in which government departments have suffered financial losses because of negligence, improper procedures, inefficient administration or other irregularities.
The purpose is not merely to identify the loss but also to determine how similar losses can be prevented in the future.
---
Role of the CAG in Relation to PAC
The Comptroller and Auditor General of India and the Public Accounts Committee have a very close institutional relationship.
The CAG independently audits government accounts and submits reports to Parliament.
The PAC then examines the findings contained in these reports.
Therefore, the CAG is sometimes described as an important aid to the Public Accounts Committee.
However, the PAC and CAG are different institutions.
CAG = audits and reports
PAC = examines and scrutinises
The CAG provides the audit findings, while the PAC examines the financial and administrative issues arising from those findings.
---
PAC and Parliamentary Financial Control
The PAC is an important instrument of legislative control over the executive.
The Constitution establishes parliamentary control over public finance. No money can be withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund of India except according to constitutional and legal procedures and parliamentary authorisation.
However, authorising expenditure before it is incurred is only one part of financial control. Parliament must also know whether the money was actually spent properly.
This is where the PAC becomes particularly important.
The Estimates Committee mainly examines estimates and suggests economies and improvements in administration, while the Public Accounts Committee examines expenditure after it has taken place, particularly through the Appropriation Accounts and CAG reports.
---
PAC and Estimates Committee: Difference
Basis| Public Accounts Committee| Estimates Committee
Main concern| Examination of expenditure already incurred| Examination of estimates of expenditure
Main sources| Appropriation Accounts, Finance Accounts and CAG reports| Budget estimates
Members| 22| 30
Lok Sabha members| 15| 30
Rajya Sabha members| 7| No Rajya Sabha members
Minister as member| Not allowed| Not allowed
Tenure| One year| One year
Chairperson| Appointed by Lok Sabha Speaker| Appointed by Lok Sabha Speaker
Main purpose| Financial accountability| Economy and efficiency in administration
---
PAC and Committee on Public Undertakings: Difference
The Parliament has three major financial committees:
1. Public Accounts Committee
2. Estimates Committee
3. Committee on Public Undertakings
The PAC mainly examines government expenditure and CAG reports.
The Estimates Committee examines budget estimates and suggests economies and improvements in administration.
The Committee on Public Undertakings examines the reports and accounts of public sector undertakings and CAG reports concerning public undertakings.
---
Importance of the Public Accounts Committee
The PAC is essential for maintaining financial accountability and parliamentary oversight.
It helps Parliament determine whether the executive has respected the financial authority granted to it.
The Committee can bring to light cases where:
- public funds were not used for the authorised purpose;
- expenditure exceeded sanctioned limits;
- financial rules were ignored;
- government resources were wasted;
- administrative negligence caused financial loss; or
- recommendations of the CAG require corrective action.
Thus, the PAC contributes to transparency, accountability, economy and financial discipline in government administration.
---
Limitations of the PAC
Although the PAC is powerful as a parliamentary scrutiny mechanism, it has certain limitations.
First, its recommendations are generally recommendatory in nature. The Committee does not itself function as a court and does not directly impose criminal or administrative punishment.
Second, the PAC generally examines expenditure after it has been incurred. Therefore, it is primarily a mechanism of post-expenditure legislative scrutiny.
Third, the Committee depends significantly on audit findings and government records for its examination.
Fourth, the Committee has a large volume of financial and audit material to examine, which can make detailed scrutiny time-consuming.
Nevertheless, the PAC remains one of the most important institutions for ensuring that the executive remains financially accountable to Parliament.
---
Significance for Indian Democracy
The Public Accounts Committee reflects the fundamental democratic principle that:
“The executive is accountable to the legislature for the use of public money.”
Parliament approves government expenditure, but parliamentary control would be incomplete if there were no mechanism to verify whether that money was spent according to the authority granted.
The PAC therefore provides an important post-expenditure check on government finances.
It strengthens:
- parliamentary accountability;
- financial discipline;
- transparency;
- responsible administration;
- legislative oversight; and
- democratic control over public expenditure.
---
Important Exam Facts
1. PAC stands for Public Accounts Committee.
2. It is one of the three major financial committees of Parliament.
3. The other two financial committees are the Estimates Committee and the Committee on Public Undertakings.
4. The PAC has 22 members.
5. 15 members are from the Lok Sabha.
6. 7 members are from the Rajya Sabha.
7. Members have a one-year tenure.
8. A minister cannot be a member of the PAC.
9. The Chairperson is appointed by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha.
10. By convention, the PAC Chairperson has generally been from the Opposition since 1967.
11. The PAC examines the Appropriation Accounts.
12. It also examines the Finance Accounts of the Union Government.
13. It examines relevant CAG reports.
14. PAC primarily performs post-expenditure scrutiny.
15. Its recommendations are generally recommendatory, not legally binding in themselves.
16. The CAG provides important audit findings that form the basis of much of PAC's scrutiny.
17. The PAC is an important instrument of legislative control over executive expenditure.
---
One-Line Definition
The Public Accounts Committee is a parliamentary financial committee that examines government expenditure, Appropriation Accounts, Finance Accounts and relevant CAG reports to ensure financial accountability and proper utilisation of public money.
Sources
- Constitution of India – provisions relating to parliamentary financial control and the Comptroller and Auditor General.
- Lok Sabha Secretariat – Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha and parliamentary committee material.
- Rajya Sabha Secretariat – Parliamentary committee material and Rules of Procedure.
- Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) – official audit reports and constitutional information.
- M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity – Parliamentary Committees and Financial Committees.
- IGNOU Study Material – Indian Parliament, Parliamentary Committees and legislative control over public finance.
Sources
Constitution of India – provisions relating to parliamentary financial control and the Comptroller and Auditor General.
Lok Sabha Secretariat – Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha and parliamentary committee material.
Rajya Sabha Secretariat – Parliamentary committee material and Rules of Procedure.
Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) – official audit reports and constitutional information.
M. Laxmikanth, Indian Polity – Parliamentary Committees and Financial Committees.
IGNOU Study Material – Indian Parliament, Parliamentary Committees and legislative control over public finance.
Comments
Post a Comment
Comment